Reviews
[ To Antietam Creek 's] sheer comprehensiveness makes it indispensable for studying the Maryland Campaign. For the first time, the entirety of the campaign, from the end of the Second Battle of Bull Run on August 30 to the night of September 16 is covered in detail... The narrative is clear and strikingly vivid, making for a compelling read... Hartwig offers a wonderful study on the battlefield commanders as well, maintaining a fair and balanced account... [T]he result is a comprehensive, engaging, and informative study., To Antietam Creek makes a very substantial contribution to the scholarship on the Maryland Campaign. It is thoroughly researched and taps previously unused sources. As the most comprehensive work available on the campaign leading up to Antietam, it will inform both historians and casual readers; its gripping narrative forcefully conveys some [of] the excitement that participants in the campaign must have felt. We should look forward to D. Scott Hartwig's concluding volume on the Battle of Antietam itself., To Antietam Creek is a masterfully detailed and exceptionally well-written narrative of the Union and Confederate perspectives on the Maryland Campaign leading up to the bloodiest day in the history of the Western Hemisphere. It skillfully examines the armies and the men who both commanded and served in them. It disentangles complicated battle narratives and provides balanced coverage of the personalities and major decisions of the campaign. Finally, it deconstructs many persistent myths about the campaign and uses abundant evidence to support its conclusions. It should serve as a definitive work on the buildup to Antietam, and its companion volume should be eagerly awaited., Hartwig has unquestionably produced the most thoroughly researched book published in this Civil War sesquicentennial period., A new and monumental study of the origins and initiation of the Maryland Campaign of 1862... To Antietam Creek is a tour de force which will stand as the preeminent and final word on the subject... A must read for any serious Civil War student interested in the crucial events leading up to the Battle of Antietam. It is an instant classic on the subject, superbly written, and a ready preface to what will be an equally important and fresh approach to the battle in a second book., "" To Antietam Creek makes a very substantial contribution to the scholarship on the Maryland Campaign. It is thoroughly researched and taps previously unused sources. As the most comprehensive work available on the campaign leading up to Antietam, it will inform both historians and casual readers; its gripping narrative forcefully conveys some [of] the excitement that participants in the campaign must have felt. We should look forward to D. Scott Hartwig's concluding volume on the Battle of Antietam itself."", The first volume of this two volume set is so very well written and all-inclusive on the detailed facts of this Maryland Campaign that it looks like this two volume set just might be the very best ever written on this campaign and battle.
Table of Content
List of Illustrations Introduction 1. The Return of McClellan "General, I am in command again" 2. The Army of Northern Virginia "Who could not conquer with troops such as these" 3. The Army of Northern Virginia Enters Maryland "Our movements will be rapid" 4. The Army of the Potomac "If we fail now the North has no hope" 5. The Army of the Potomac Advances to Frederick "You may be sure that I will follow them as closely as I can" 5. Harpers Ferry "To the last extremity" 7. The Battle for Mary land Heights "For God's sake, don't fall back" 8. September 13 "My general idea is to cut the enemy in two" 9. The Morning Battle for Fox's Gap "My God! Be careful!" 10. Afternoon at Fox's Gap "So little did we know of the etiquette of war" 11. The First Corps Attacks "It looked like a task to storm" 12. The Battle for Hill 1280 "Some of you will get hurt" 13. Into Turner's Gap "An ugly looking place to attack" 14. Crampton's Gap "The best fighting that has been done in this war" 15. Retreat from South Mountain "God has seldom given an army a greater victory than this" 16. The Trap Closes and a Cavalry Dash "The fate of Harper's Ferry was sealed" 17. The Fall of Harpers Ferry "Through God's blessing, Harper's Ferry and its garrison are to be surrendered" 18. September 16 "We are entirely too methodical" 19. Eve of Battle "I shall not, however, soon forget that night" Acknowledgments Appendixes a. Opposing Forces in the Mary and Campaign b. Strength of Union and Confederate Forces c. Union and Confederate Casualties List of Abbreviations Notes Essay on Sources Index, List of Illustrations Introduction 1. The Return of McClellan ""General, I am in command again"" 2. The Army of Northern Virginia ""Who could not conquer with troops such as these"" 3. The Army of Northern Virginia Enters Maryland ""Our movements will be rapid"" 4. The Army of the Potomac ""If we fail now the North has no hope"" 5. The Army of the Potomac Advances to Frederick ""You may be sure that I will follow them as closely as I can"" 5. Harpers Ferry ""To the last extremity"" 7. The Battle for Mary land Heights ""For God's sake, don't fall back"" 8. September 13 ""My general idea is to cut the enemy in two"" 9. The Morning Battle for Fox's Gap ""My God! Be careful!"" 10. Afternoon at Fox's Gap ""So little did we know of the etiquette of war"" 11. The First Corps Attacks ""It looked like a task to storm"" 12. The Battle for Hill 1280 ""Some of you will get hurt"" 13. Into Turner's Gap ""An ugly looking place to attack"" 14. Crampton's Gap ""The best fighting that has been done in this war"" 15. Retreat from South Mountain ""God has seldom given an army a greater victory than this"" 16. The Trap Closes and a Cavalry Dash ""The fate of Harper's Ferry was sealed"" 17. The Fall of Harpers Ferry ""Through God's blessing, Harper's Ferry and its garrison are to be surrendered"" 18. September 16 ""We are entirely too methodical"" 19. Eve of Battle ""I shall not, however, soon forget that night"" Acknowledgments Appendixes a. Opposing Forces in the Mary and Campaign b. Strength of Union and Confederate Forces c. Union and Confederate Casualties List of Abbreviations Notes Essay on Sources Index
